Late-afternoon light grazes a mature oak and a low granite wall beside a quiet woodland path, with muted November foliage.

Argonne Forest Sits Between the Two Ends of an 1872 Will

November 12, 2026

In the spring of 1980, the congregation of New Hope African Methodist Episcopal Church was celebrating its 111th anniversary. After Sunday morning service, members left the church on Arden Road and walked in procession several blocks to Harmony Grove Cemetery. There they held a service of thanksgiving and laid a wreath on the grave of a farmer named James H. Smith.

Both ends of that walk border Argonne Forest. The city's official boundaries run the neighborhood along West Paces Ferry Road on the north and Arden Road on the southeast. Harmony Grove sits on West Paces Ferry and New Hope sits on Arden. This year, both sites were slated for formal public recognition. New Hope became a City of Atlanta historic landmark in June, and Buckhead Heritage set the dedication of a new historic marker at Harmony Grove for Saturday, Nov. 14.

One farmer, two parcels, eight days

Before the Civil War, James H. "Whispering" Smith farmed 405 acres in Buckhead. The 1860 Slave Schedule lists him as the owner of eight enslaved people, as Wright Mitchell wrote in a 2009 Rough Draft Atlanta column.

The New Hope congregation was organized in 1869 and worshipped at the New Hope Camp Ground along Arden Road. On May 29, 1872, Smith signed a will leaving two parcels of farmland for a church and a school: two acres for the church and one for a schoolhouse. He died eight days later. Buckhead Heritage quotes the church's National Register nomination, which says that is how the congregation became the legal owner of the ground its church and cemetery still stand on.

The congregation was already well established before it owned that land. In the same Rough Draft column, Mitchell described camp meetings on the fourth Sunday of August that drew people from across the South. Families raised livestock months in advance, and many visitors camped overnight. At the close of each meeting, worshippers walked around the plank tabernacle seven times singing "The Year of the Jubilee Has Come."

The church history on New Hope's own site carries the same 1869 founding date and the same will.

Harmony Grove, at the other end

Smith was buried two years after his infant son, who was also named James. The boy died on March 4, 1870, and his is the earliest recorded burial at Harmony Grove. The cemetery covers a little less than an acre on a small rise at the southwest corner of West Paces Ferry and Chatham Roads. It holds at least 171 burials. Only 40 of the graves have traditional inscribed headstones, and the rest are unmarked or marked with fieldstones.

The cemetery's name comes from a church that no longer stands. Its earliest documented record is an 1889 deed conveying the land to Harmony Grove Congregational Church for church and burial purposes. The congregation became Harmony Grove Baptist Church in 1903, and the building was probably torn down in the early 1920s. Burials continued for decades afterward. The last was Charlotte Krause's in 1982. Buckhead Heritage counts Confederate veterans, prominent local businessmen, the father of entertainer Dorothy Shay and the great-grandparents of actress Julia Roberts among those buried there.

The well-kept grounds that West Paces Ferry drivers pass today are fairly recent. Atlanta Magazine reported that Wright Mitchell came across the site in 2005, when it was overgrown. Restoring it became the first project of the new Buckhead Heritage Society. The work began in April 2006 and came in three phases. Crews first cleared groundcover and debris. Mortuary archaeologists then mapped the marked and unmarked graves. Last came a landscape plan with a stone path and new plantings. In 2009 the Georgia Trust for Historic Preservation gave the rehabilitation its Preservation Award for Excellence in Rehabilitation.

That same spring, the two burial grounds were tied together formally. The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported that New Hope's cemetery and Harmony Grove were consecrated in a joint ceremony.

How the two sites have marked each other

Year New Hope, Arden Road Harmony Grove, West Paces Ferry and Chatham
1869 Congregation organized at the New Hope Camp Ground
1870 First recorded burial, Smith's infant son
1872 Smith's will deeds land for the church and school Smith is buried here
1889 First documented burial in the church cemetery Deed to Harmony Grove Congregational Church
1936 Sanctuary completed
1980 Anniversary procession to Smith's grave Wreath laid by the New Hope congregation
2009 Joint consecration of both cemeteries Georgia Trust award for the restoration
2026 City landmark designation in June Historic marker dedication set for Nov. 14

Three public steps in five months

The 2026 recognitions came close together. WABE reported that the City of Atlanta designated New Hope a historic landmark in June. At its Aug. 17 meeting, the Atlanta City Council presented the church with a proclamation and formal recognition. WABE quoted Councilwoman Mary Norwood at that presentation: "Generations of congregants have worshiped on the same property as the church has served as a hub of activity, a gathering spot, and a specific point of reference in the fabric of the city of Atlanta."

In the same report, Atlanta History Center historian La'Neice Littleton described the church as "the nucleus" of Buckhead's historic African American neighborhoods, naming Johnsontown and Macedonia Park, also called Bagley Park. The cemetery across Arden Road is listed on the National Register of Historic Places along with the church. It covers 1.86 acres and holds hundreds of graves, many of them unmarked.

At Harmony Grove, Buckhead Heritage set the marker dedication for Saturday, Nov. 14, at 2 p.m., with Sunday, Nov. 15, as the rain date. Wright Mitchell, now president and CEO of the Georgia Trust for Historic Preservation, was scheduled to speak about the cemetery's history and how Buckhead Heritage came to care for it. The organization also planned to honor the marker's major donors, the DAR Atlanta Chapter and The George M. Brown Trust Fund of Atlanta among them. Buckhead Heritage has looked after the cemetery since 2006.

The building on Arden Road needs the most work

Harmony Grove's restoration is complete. New Hope's is just beginning. The church's preservation campaign covers the historic sanctuary, the Life Center and the grounds, and it says the sanctuary can no longer safely hold the congregation for worship.

The building has been rebuilt before. After a fire in 1927, the remains of the wooden-frame church were encased in stone in 1928, and the sanctuary was added in 1936, according to Littleton in the WABE report. Paying for that 1936 sanctuary was hard. Mitchell's 2009 Rough Draft column says congregation members Beatrice Bogan and Ana Jones put up their own property to secure the loans that started construction under the Rev. W.W. Stephens.

Pastor David F. Richards III told WABE the preservation project is in its early phases. It will include cemetery upkeep, structural and roof restoration, and a modern sanctuary with recording capabilities. He described the goal in the same interview:

"They'd want the structure of the sanctuary and the church building to be held intact but able to be used for another 157 years."

Visiting both this season

The two sites are close enough to see in one short outing.

  1. Harmony Grove Cemetery, southwest corner of West Paces Ferry and Chatham Roads. For the marker dedication, Buckhead Heritage told attendees to park along Chatham Road. The organization encourages respectful exploration and photography at the historic Buckhead cemeteries it looks after. The stone path from the third phase of the restoration leads through the grounds.
  2. New Hope A.M.E. Church, 3012 Arden Road NW. The church lists Sunday worship at 11 a.m.
  3. New Hope Cemetery, across Arden Road from the church. The entrance has a wrought-iron gate and two stone pillars placed in memory of church member Oscar Turner, an Army sergeant who received the Bronze Star Medal. Military markers from World War II, the Korean War and the Vietnam War stand among the graves, and earlier research counted at least ten veterans buried there.

Buckhead Heritage's calendar continues with its Holiday Gathering on Sunday, Dec. 13, from 6:30 to 9 p.m. It will be held at the Calhoun-Thornwell Estate, the 1923 Italianate mansion designed by Hentz, Reid & Adler and also known as the Pink Castle. Tickets on the Buckhead Heritage events page are $175 for members and $200 for nonmembers. For more about the streets between these two sites, the Argonne Forest neighborhood guide covers the area from West Paces Ferry down to Arden.

Mary Stuart Iverson is a third-generation Atlantan, and she follows how this part of Buckhead looks after its oldest places. If you live near Arden Road or West Paces Ferry and want to talk about your corner of Argonne Forest, Mary Stuart Iverson would be glad to hear from you. Schedule a Free Consultation.

Work With Mary Stuart

Mary Stuart Iverson is a member of Who’s Who In Luxury Real Estate / LuxuryRealEstate.com, an international network of real estate professionals operating in 195 countries and representing the finest residential luxury estates and property brokerages in the world.